Reviews — Classic Cars For Sale

MGA

MGA REVIEW

If you’re not bowled over by the looks – and you almost certainly will be – then the driving experience should be enough to convince you of the MGA’s pedigree. Even in lower-powered 1500 form, the MGA is a perky performer, although the more powerful engines do add a welcome turn of speed. But that’s not really what this car is all about. What it does exceedingly well for a car of this vintage is ride and handle with real aplomb, which makes it a classic that you really can use every day, even for the longest of journeys. A combination of independent front suspension and rack and pinion steering provide accurate control, and even with a live rear axle ride comfort is more than acceptable. There isn’t much body roll either which makes tackling a twisty B-road an enjoyable experience, while the drum brakes are more than powerful enough to inspire confidence. The functional cabin is a touch on the snug side for taller drivers but it’s easy enough to get comfortable, and all the controls are well-placed.

VITAL STATISTICS

Engine: 1588cc/4-cyl/OHV

Power: 80bhp@5500rpm

Torque: 87lb ft@3800rpm

Maximum speed: 101mph

0-60mph: 14.2sec

Fuel consumption: 24-26mpg

Transmission: RWD, 5-spd man+O/D

 

WHAT TO LOOK FOR

1 When you consider a professional restoration can exceed £30,000, the need to be sure of the car’s condition becomes clear. Unless you’re absolutely certain about the quality of previous restoration, finding another car – even one in need of work – may be the better option. Panel fit is a good guide to overall condition so check the shutlines around the doors and bonnet/wings – major variance here should ring alarm bells. Rot is a serious issue too, the inner and outer sills, A-pillars, wings, and door bottoms the main indicators of problems beneath. The boot lid, bonnet (both of which contain a plywood panel that can harbour rot), and door skins are aluminium panels over steel frames, so galvanic corrosion needs to be checked for as well.  

2 The separate chassis will need careful checking. Rot-spots include the front and rear cross-members, the battery boxes, the chassis rails along the sills and around the pillars, and the rear spring hangers. While underneath, take a good look at the wooden floors which are susceptible to rotting-out, paying particular attention to the points where they attach to the chassis. Crash damage may have distorted the chassis and the car will never be right if it’s been ignored – again those panel shutlines are the best indicator of hidden problems. Getting the car on a jig is the only way to be sure.

3 A variety of engines were fitted over the years, initially a 1500cc B-Series unit and from 1959 a more powerful 1600cc lump. Neither hold particular worries for buyers, although there are a few areas to check. Oil leaks are common, often caused by the oil-thrower at the rear of the crankshaft and a seal conversion is available to cure the problem. However, anything more than a few small drips will require a proper re-build. Worn piston rings or bores will cause excessive blue smoke from the exhaust, and it’s worth checking for any signs of head gasket failure as water leaks and cracked cylinder heads are common issues. Steady water temperature and around 50psi of oil pressure when warm are good signs on a test drive. Engine mods (or indeed complete engine swaps) such as bigger carburettors and cylinder head conversions are popular with owners.

4 More troublesome is the Twin Cam engine, in production for just a couple of years. Not only did it have a reputation for drinking oil – poor piston-ring design was to blame – but changes in fuel mixture strength led to many a melted piston. Most will have been sorted by now, but they are tricky and expensive to re-build correctly, so we’d advise a specialist inspection if you fancy one of these.

5 The four-speed manual gearbox can prove troublesome. In particular,  disintegrating second gear synchromesh and worn layshaft bearings are the main issues (a chattering noise in first or reverse gears signifies the latter.) Many will have been rebuilt or replaced, so check the history for previous work. Some cars have been converted to a five-speed set-up using a Ford Sierra gearbox – purists may frown but it’s not a problem as long as the job was done properly. Listen-out for a whining differential and check that worn bearings haven’t allowed oil to leak from the axle casing onto the brakes.

6 The drum brakes on early models are effective with proper maintenance, but a conversion to the later front disc arrangement is a popular – if largely unnecessary – mod. The kingpins/trunnions need regular greasing to prevent wear and seizure, so beware of stiff steering, while leaking lever arm dampers and tired rear leaf springs are other issues to watch for. Original buyers had a choice of steel disc or wire wheels (twin cam models used Dunlop centre-lock items), and these are often swapped depending on preference. Wires look good but ensure spokes and splines are in good condition as professional re-builds aren’t cheap.

7 The good news is that just about all interior trim parts are available, so a tatty cabin isn’t a deal breaker, but costs will soon mount if a complete re-trim is required. Poor restoration may be more trouble than it’s worth, so an original car in need
of work may be a better bet. Plenty of cars end
up with parts from other MG models in a bid to keep restoration costs down, which will adversely affect values.

OUR VERDICT
While the MGA might appear simple in design there are enough pitfalls to make a rash purchase unwise. That shouldn’t put you off this fine British classic – it just means that you need to take a little care and preferably engage the services of a reputable specialist to ensure you don’t land yourself with someone else’s bodged restoration. Get it wrong and a world of financial pain awaits. Be patient and you’ll have one of the finest classic sports cars out there.

 

Share

MGA TWIN-CAM REVIEW

Too specialised for mass-production in the 1950s, but modern tweaks make them work.

After years of languishing with largely pre-war designs, the very good-looking and well-performing MGA of 1955 gave MG a new optimism, as well as won new customers. Its success meant rapid development, with the original 1489cc engine being upgraded to 1588cc in 1959 and then 1622cc for 1961. A coupe complemented the original convertible in 1956 and there were numerous other nips and tucks to gradually improve the breed.

But not every change was for the better, however well-intentioned. The MGA Twin-Cam of 1958 was an innovative attempt to build an even more performance-orientated version capable of what the market was asking for: a 100mph MG. For this, the 1588cc B-series engine was reqorked with twin overhead camshafts and an alloy cylinder head. however, the engine proved temperamental, being prone to detonation and burning oil and in need of constant tuning.

The warranty claims were extensive and so, after two years and 2111 examples, the Twin Cam was discontinued in June 1960. Understanding owners have made it a more reliable proposition.

 

VITAL STATISTICS

Engine: 1588cc/4-cyl/DOHC

Power: 108bhp@6500rpm

Torque: 104lb ft@4500rpm

Maximum speed: 114mph

0-60mph: 13.3sec

Fuel consumption: 23-25mpg

Transmission: RWD, four-spd manual

 

WHAT TO LOOK OUT FOR

Bodywork

Especially vulnerable grot spots are the sills and A-posts, but wings also go, so check everywhere thoroughly. Door bottoms go frilly, as does the boot floor. The doors themselves are aluminium over steel, as are the bootlid and bonnet, but the combination of these two metals together can cause electrolytic corrosion. Both the bonnet and bootlid have a wooden stiffener, whic rots. Look for good panel gaps - any uneven or big apertures and/or rippling points to possible accident damage and possibly a twisted chassis.

Chassis

The chassis is quite tough, but if you do suspect an accident then get underneath to look for any kinks or ripples. Focus in the front and rear chassis legs for any issues, and check the integrity of the wooden floorboard supports.

Engine

Don't think that because the twin-cam engine started life as a good ol' B-series, it will be cheap and easy to fix. It won't as it requires expert and expensive knowledge. Be suspicious of any engine that is noisy up top or runs badly - burnt pistons can strike, although it's less likely on later low compression cars. Disconnecting the distributor vacuum advance genuinely makes the engine run better. Oil pressure should be 50psi at 3500rpm and oil consumption is around a pint every 200 miles. Watch for blue smoke from the exhaust and be wary of hit running. Check for possible head gasket issues such as water and oil mixing and mayonnaise under the oil filler cap.

Transmission

Gearboxes can also be troublesome, with second gear synchromesh likely to start disappearing. Chattering in first and reverse is also a sign of all not being well. Loose hub nuts can allow the differential to spin against the axle casing, which will damage both items.

Brakes and suspension

The Dunlop disc brakes can suffer from binding or scoring if the calipers have seized, something the rear ones are quite prone to . Worn or tight suspension trunnions are also quite common, along with leaking or worn-out lever arm dampers. Check the gaiters on the rack-and-pinion steering to make sure they haven't split, as this will water and mud in.

Interior

Most interior trim is available and replaceable. Look for pitting of any Mazak parts and damaged vinyl dash covering. The electrics are Lucas - so expect the unexpected sometimes - but again everything is available to rectify any issues.

OUR VERDICT

The Twin-Cam is the most desirable of all classic MGs, and prices reflect this; a Roadster version is worth more than twice the value of an MGC. The extra performance and the four-wheel disc brakes make it very usable and capable in modern traffic conditions, in a way few other 1950s cars can. It is thoroughly entertaining to drive. Then there are the looks - the flowing Sid Evener shape puts it not just among the most attractive of MGs, but also the most beautiful of all British cars. There's also the perverse satisfaction of owning something that once was so problematical. Because, as a modern owner, you get to experience the MGA's true potential, in a way denied to those who bought them originally.